Microsoft .NET Code Analysis: Enums Should Always Have a Zero Value

When reviewing code, I often encounter a common issue: the lack of a default or “not set” value for enums. This aspect is significant in most situations as it assists in indicating when a value has not been assigned. Allow me to provide an example to illustrate the problem:

public enum UserRole
{
    Administrator = 1,
    Guest = 2,
    Service = 3
}

This serves as a perfect illustration because, in this scenario, a user’s role should be initially set as “none” until it is assigned by the code after the user has been authenticated. Here’s the suggested approach to resolve this problem:

public enum UserRole
{
    NotAuthorized = 0,
    Administrator = 1,
    Guest = 2,
    Service = 3
}

Here is a comprehensive list of reasons highlighting the significance of including a zero value when defining an enum:

1. Default initialization: When an enum variable is declared without explicitly assigning a value, it is automatically initialized to the first element, which is the zero value. This ensures that enum variables always have a valid initial value.
2. Implicit conversions: Enums in .NET are essentially a set of named integral constants, where each constant is assigned a unique value. Having a zero value allows implicit conversions between enums and their underlying integral type (usually int). For example, you can assign an enum value to an int variable and vice versa without requiring explicit casting.
3. Error handling and default cases: Enum values are often used in switch statements or as return values from methods. By convention, developers often define a “default” or “unknown” value as the zero value, which can be used as a catch-all case or to indicate an invalid or uninitialized state.

When working with enums, it is essential to validate them when they are utilized as parameters for methods or properties. In .NET, enums are assigned the integer type by default. As a result, even if specific values like 0, 1, 2, and 3 are defined for an enum, it is still possible to pass any valid integer value into the method. To ensure proper validation, always use the Enum.IsDefined() method. Alternatively, you can make use of the ArgumentDefined() or CheckIsDefined() functions provided by DotNetTips.Spargine.Core NuGet package.

When I setup the CA1008 code analysis in my .editorConfig it looks like this: dotnet_diagnostic.CA1008.severity = warning

Summary

During my review of the codebase for this article, I identified 8 instances where this issue occurs.

For further guidance and insights, I highly recommend obtaining a copy of my book, “Rock Your Code: Coding Standards for Microsoft .NET” available on Amazon.com. Additionally, to explore more performance tips for .NET, I encourage you to acquire the 3rd edition of “Rock Your Code: Code & App Performance for Microsoft .NET” also available on Amazon.com.

To analyze your code using the same settings I used in these articles, I encourage you to incorporate my EditorConfig file. It can be found at the following link: https://bit.ly/dotNetDaveEditorConfig. I update this file quarterly, so remember to keep yours up to date as well. I hope you will check out my OSS project Spargine by using this link: https://bit.ly/Spargine.

Please feel free to leave a comment below. I would appreciate hearing your thoughts and feedback.

Pick up any books by David McCarter by going to Amazon.com: http://bit.ly/RockYourCodeBooks

If you liked this article, please buy David a cup of Coffee by going here: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/dotnetdave

© The information in this article is copywritten and cannot be preproduced in any way without express permission from David McCarter.